The Will to Escape – 3: The Fragility of a Life Without Suffering

Weathered stone arch framing a winding river and mountain valley

Protection, Endurance, and the Loss of Maturity

We have become remarkably successful at making life easier. Technology protects us from physical hardship, medicine relieves pain and extends life, and social institutions increasingly seek to shield individuals from deprivation, uncertainty, and distress. These are considerable achievements, and their value does not need to be questioned.

Yet something curious is happening alongside this progress. The more we organise life around comfort, protection, and personal well-being, the more difficult we seem to find it to endure what cannot be avoided. Frustration, disappointment, loneliness, uncertainty, and emotional pain increasingly appear as disturbances that should not be part of a good life.

The implicit expectation is that a good life should contain as little suffering as possible. But what happens when this expectation becomes the measure by which we judge not only our experiences, but also our relationships and responsibilities?

The Disappearance of the Passage

In earlier societies, growing up was rarely understood as a simple extension of childhood. It involved entering a different relationship with the world, assuming responsibilities, and accepting obligations that could not always be reconciled with personal wishes. Rites of passage gave these transitions a visible form. Initiation, marriage, parenthood, mourning, and other significant experiences were surrounded by practices that acknowledged their difficulty and marked their significance within the community.

These traditions were far from perfect. They could impose unnecessary suffering, reinforce inequalities, and demand submission to structures that deserved to be questioned. Their disappearance has brought genuine freedoms. Yet something else has weakened alongside them: a shared understanding that certain responsibilities and difficulties belong to our participation in human life.

The difficulties themselves have not disappeared. Growing up, loving, caring, losing, and accepting responsibility remain demanding experiences. But increasingly, they are encountered as private problems to be managed rather than as dimensions of a shared existence.

We are expected to find our own way, yet we have fewer shared meanings through which to understand what that way demands of us. The individual is left increasingly alone to determine what matters, what is worth enduring, and what obligations are compatible with personal fulfilment.

The Difficulty of Enduring

There is an important difference between suffering and the capacity to endure suffering.

Endurance does not mean glorifying pain, accepting preventable harm, or refusing help when help is needed. It means being able to remain present when life does not conform to our expectations, when something cannot be immediately resolved, and when another person’s needs make demands upon us.

To love someone is to be vulnerable to their suffering. To raise a child means accepting responsibilities that cannot always be postponed or negotiated. To remain beside someone through illness means allowing another person’s needs to enter our lives in ways we cannot control.

None of this is necessarily a denial of ourselves. It reveals that our existence is not self-contained, and that our involvement with others cannot be reduced to what we choose, desire, or find convenient.

Suffering does not automatically make us wiser or more compassionate. It can also close us in fear and resentment. Nor is hardship a prerequisite for maturity. But the capacity to remain present when life becomes difficult is essential to relationships whose significance extends beyond our immediate satisfaction.

This is where growing up becomes more than acquiring independence. It involves recognising that our lives are bound to others in ways that cannot be reduced to choice, convenience, or personal fulfilment.

Maturity is not the achievement of a life in which we no longer depend on others. It is the recognition of the significance of that dependence and of the responsibilities that accompany it.

What Protection Cannot Give Us

Perhaps the paradox of our time is that, while we have become increasingly capable of protecting individuals from external difficulties, we have not necessarily become more capable of living with one another.

The individual is encouraged to preserve personal autonomy, avoid unnecessary discomfort, and pursue fulfilment. Yet meaningful relationships inevitably make demands that cannot always be accommodated within this arrangement. They require attention, patience, and the recognition of needs that do not originate in ourselves.

When every disturbance is regarded as an obstacle to well-being, the very conditions through which our involvement with others becomes apparent may begin to appear as threats.

This does not mean that every relationship must be preserved, that every obligation is legitimate, or that personal boundaries should be abandoned. Nor does it mean that suffering should be accepted simply because it arises within a relationship.

The question is rather whether, in seeking to remove everything that makes life difficult, we have also begun to lose sight of the significance of what makes demands upon us.

Perhaps maturity does not consist in becoming invulnerable, independent, or permanently fulfilled. It involves recognising that our existence is already bound up with others, and that their significance does not depend entirely on how they make us feel or what they can offer us.

We can make life safer, easier, and more comfortable. These are worthwhile achievements. But we cannot thereby make ourselves independent of others or eliminate the demands that arise from our involvement in existence.

To grow beyond oneself is not to overcome the need for others. It is to discover that our existence was never ours alone.


Discover more from It Is What It Is

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply